Owning a rare Frank Lloyd Wright home is a dream come true for many architecture enthusiasts. However, it's not without its challenges. The article explores the complexities of maintaining these iconic structures, using the example of Petra Island in upstate New York. The 5,000-square-foot main house, built from Wright's original plans, showcases the architect's creativity but also presents maintenance issues. The flat roof leaks, and oversized fireplaces smoke, requiring frequent and painstaking upkeep. This is a common struggle for owners of Wright's roughly 400 still-standing houses, many concentrated in the Midwest. Wright's designs, while prioritizing artistry, often prioritized practicality over functionality, leading to maintenance challenges. The article delves into the personal experiences of owners, like Joe Massaro, who invest significant resources in preserving these architectural treasures. It highlights the romanticism of Wright's work, attracting buyers like Marika Broere and Tony Hillebrandt, who restore Wright homes in Michigan. However, the article also emphasizes the financial burden and specialized craftsmanship required to maintain these structures. The Chicago-based Frank Lloyd Wright Building Conservancy recognizes the dedication of historic house owners, but also acknowledges the challenges of preserving older homes, including those by mid-century architects. The article concludes by exploring the allure of Wright's designs and the efforts of owners like Massaro, who turn their passion into a business by offering tours of their Wright-designed island.
